生酮飲食

 

回到首頁

  • 更新日期:2017-10-26

  • 生酮飲食(Ketogetic Diet)顧名思義,就是能產生酮體的飲食。藉由減少會生成葡萄糖的食物攝取量,例如:非纖維的碳水化合物與某些胺基酸(glucogenic amino acids),逼迫身體分解脂肪酸,製造酮體(ketone bodies)來供應能量,也就是讓身體的能源系統從燃燒葡萄糖為主轉換為燃燒酮體為主。

  • 生酮飲食是一種超低醣、低蛋白、高脂肪的飲食。(通常脂肪攝取量占總熱量的80%以上)

  • Dr. Russel Wilder為了複製斷食的療效,特地模仿斷食的營養狀態(超低醣、低蛋白、高脂),設計了一套能產生酮體的飲食法,並把它命名為【生酮飲食】。

  • 每天實施【間歇性斷食】有助於切換成生酮狀態! 

【禁忌症】

  • 原發性肉鹼缺乏症(Primary carnitine deficiency)

  • 脂肪酸氧化途徑缺陷

  • 遺傳性丙酮酸羧化酶缺乏(pyruvate carboxylase deficiency)

  • 紫質症(porphyria)

【生酮不適症】

  • 請參考→生酮不適症(Keto-flu)

  • Dr. Stephen Phinney建議生酮飲食者,每日的鈉攝取量至少要5公克,而美國政府建議的上限只有2.3公克,不足以應付生酮飲食的鈉流失。

  • 加拿大的研究發現,每日5克的鈉,心血管疾病死亡率最低,不是美國政府的2.3克。

  •  5公克的鈉=12.7克的鹽巴。(這是大約值,會因不 同品牌鹽巴的雜質含量不同而得出不同的換算值。)

  • 生酮不適症,最簡單的解決辦法是口含一點點的玫瑰鹽。可事先研磨一些玫瑰鹽擺在小碟子上,不舒服時就用手指捏一些撒在嘴裡含著,不要配水,讓鹽巴慢慢溶化。

  • 含鹽的準則是:少量多次為原則。如果鹽巴無法含在嘴裡慢慢溶化而必須馬上配水喝,就是代表量太多了,下次必須減量才行!

  • 鹽巴的選擇:粗鹽或玫瑰鹽皆可,禁止精製白鹽。

【生酮飲食總熱量比例】

  • 各種版本的生酮飲食總熱量比例:
     

     

    醣類%

    蛋白質%

    脂肪%

    Eric Crall版生酮飲食

    5

    20

    75

    Eric Berg版生酮飲食

    5~10

    25

    65~80

    Ellen Davis治癌生酮飲食

    2~4

    9~11

    65~80

  • 使用熱量比例來創造生酮狀態是比較不可靠的,因為總熱量過多,換算出來的生糖物質會過多,阻斷生酮的機會。例如:如果每日攝取2000卡,相當於攝取了25克醣類(2000*5%≒4),即使加入某些蛋白質的生糖量,萄萄糖的總量不至於太高,生酮的機率就非常大,反之,如果每日攝取總量是4500卡,相當於攝取了56.25克醣類(4500*5%≒4),再加上某些蛋白質的生糖量,萄萄糖的總量就會太多,生酮的機率就相對變小了。

  • 根據胺基酸的生糖與生酮能力來分類:1.可生糖的氨基酸,2.可生酮的胺基酸,3.二者皆可的胺基酸。

     

    可生糖的氨基酸

    二者皆可的胺基酸

    可生酮的胺基酸

    非必需胺基酸

    Alanine(丙胺酸)
    Arginine(精氨酸)
    Asparagine(天門冬醯胺)

    Aspartate(天門冬氨酸)

    Cysteine(半胱氨酸)

    Glutamate(谷氨酸)

    Glutamine(谷氨醯胺)

    Glycine(甘氨酸)

    Proline(脯氨酸)

    Serine(絲氨酸)

    Tyrosine(酪氨酸)

     

    必須胺基酸

    Histidine(组氨酸)

    Methionine(甲硫氨酸)

    Valine(纈氨酸)

    Isoleucine(異亮氨酸)

    Phenylalanine(苯丙氨酸)

    Tryptophan(色氨酸)

    Threonine(蘇氨酸)

    Leucine(白氨酸)

    Lysine(離胺酸)

 

【各種生酮狀態】

  • 狀態

    血酮濃度
    (Beta-OHB,mmol/L)

    混合飲食

    0.1~0.2

    一夜斷食(混合飲食)

    <0.5

    營養性生酮狀態

    0.5~5.0

    醫療性生酮狀態

    2.0~7.0

    飢餓

    5.0~8.0

    糖尿病酮酸血症

    15~20

     

  • 生酮聖經版本(The Ketogenic Bible)

    狀態

    酮體

    血糖

    血液pH 結果

    正常醣類飲食

    0~0.4

    80~120

    不變

     

    斷食

    生酮飲食

    0.5~7

    60~120

    不變

    改善健康

    糖尿病酮酸血症

    >15~25

    >200

    極酸性

    可能致命

 

【生酮飲食的攝取量】

  • 要進入生酮狀態,血糖必須降低到55~75之間,光靠限制醣類是不夠的,還必須限制蛋白質與總卡路里。

  • 限制蛋白質是要減少蛋白質透過糖質新生作用轉化成葡萄糖,同時減少癌細胞的糧食之一:麩醯胺酸(Glutamine)。

  • 醣類的攝取量必須降低到每日25克以下。(JK補充:生酮飲食的眾多版本中,幾乎都規定每日醣類攝取量要低於50克。)

  • 若要迅速降血糖升酮體,建議每日淨糖值要低於12克。(淨糖值=醣類-纖維)

  • 蛋白質的攝取量必須降低到每日50~70克,大約是肌肉維修所需的最低量。換算公式是:
    每日蛋白質攝取量=1公克蛋白質/每公斤標準體重。(不能採用真實體重,要改採對應身高的標準體重。)

  • 根據Ron Rosedale的最新研究,一般人的蛋白質攝取量應該降到0.75克/每公斤淨瘦肉體重,甚至更低,這樣才能降低mTOR,讓身體進入維修狀態,減少糖尿病、癌症、肥胖的罹患機率。而已經罹患糖尿病或癌症者,必須攝取更低的蛋白質。
    糖尿病:低於0.6克/每公斤淨瘦肉體重
    癌症:低於0.45克/每公斤淨瘦肉體重

    (淨瘦肉體重=體重-體脂)

  • 過量蛋白質→激發mTORPKAIGF→抑制幹細胞生成、抑制自我吞噬作用。

  • Ron Rosedale指出:高蛋白質會升高IGF,而IGF與癌症、老化有關。

  • Ron Rosedale警告說:當今社會,限制蛋白質可能比限制醣類還重要!

  • Volek & Phinney版的生酮飲食蛋白質攝取量:
    註:超過最高攝取量即脫離生酮狀態。

    生酮飲食的蛋白質攝取量

     

    最低量

    最高量

    每磅體重

    0.6

    1.0

    每公斤體重

    1.3

    2.2

  • 生酮飲食的食物→http://www.ketogenic-diet-resource.com/low-carb-food-list.html

【斷食Vs生酮飲食】

  • 肝醣沒用完,肝臟是不會大量燃燒脂肪來製造酮體,而人體的肝醣儲備量大約12小時就用完了(有的統計是肝醣要24~36小時才會耗 盡),所以每天只要空腹12~18小時或更長的時間,身體就會從燃燒葡萄糖的系統切換到燃燒脂肪的系統。舉例,如果每天的最後一餐是中午12點的午餐,那就要等到半夜12點身體才會開始大量燃燒脂肪製造酮體。以此類推,如果最後一餐是8點的晚餐,那就要等到隔天早上8點才會大量燃燒脂肪製造酮體。如果早上8點又吃了早餐,那就沒有機會大量燃燒脂肪製造酮體了 ,因此建議每天的【用餐時間】要集中在6~8個小時內完成,其他時間都要嚴格禁食。

  • Adam-Perrott的研究顯示,生酮飲食的肝醣耗盡時間約48小時,生酮速度比斷食慢一些,因為生酮飲食還是會吃進少量醣類,延後肝醣耗盡的時間。

【如何讓血糖降低到55~75之間?】

  • 一般正常人的空腹血糖是維持在83左右,即使完全不吃碳水化合物也無法把血糖降到55~75之間,必須再配合限制卡路里與限制蛋白質攝取量,才能讓血糖降低到55~75之間。 

  • 生酮研究者Dominic D’Agostino 刻意用生酮飲食來製造極低的血糖濃度(25mg/dL),一般人肯定會陷入昏迷狀態,但Dominic D’Agostino沒有,因為他能使用酮體當燃料。另外還有研究者創下更低的血糖紀錄,18 mg/dL。大家知道有這麼回事就好,不要去模仿,以免危險。

【酮體的代謝】

  • 酮體是脂肪酸燃燒的副產品,不是最終產物,必須再進一步燃燒才行,否則就會從尿中排出。

  • 酮體恰好可以提供無法直接燃燒脂肪酸的組織當燃料,例如大腦。

  • 酮體不只是大腦與心臟的極佳燃料,而且身體的周圍組織也能利用酮體,但是肝臟只會製造酮體,無法使用酮體,因為肝臟缺乏琥珀酰輔酶A轉移酵素(succinyl CoA transferase)。

  • 酮體分為左旋與右璇,右旋酮體是最乾淨的燃料,產生較少的活性氧化物質(ROS),有保護粒線體的作用,而粒線體健康,細胞核就不會突變,細胞也不會癌化。左旋酮體則比較像脂肪酸,產生較多的活性氧化物質。另外,左旋酮體還會消散質子動力梯度(proton-motive gradient),降低右璇酮體的能源效率。

  • 右旋酮體可以從中鏈脂肪酸的食物中獲得,例如:椰子油。

  • 思考:科學家已經可以利用化學方式去製造右璇酮體,但是人類的主要脂肪燃料是脂肪酸,不是酮體,酮體只是脂肪酸燃燒過程的副產品而已,如果大量直接補充酮體,一定會改變脂肪燃燒的能源分布比例,到底會有啥後遺症不得而知。我們之所以提倡生酮飲食,是因為我們從斷食中看到了若干好處,我們才去模仿斷食而設計出生酮飲食,現在我們改變斷食特有的脂肪燃料比例,改變了脂肪酸為主的燃燒方式,是好是壞,還有待科學家去追蹤!

酮體的精準測量】

  • 測量是否進入生酮狀態最精準的方法是測量血液中β-丁酸鹽-hydroxybutyrate)的濃度,其次是測量呼吸中的丙酮(acetone)濃度,最不準確的是測量尿液中的乙酰乙酸鹽(acetoacetate)。通常進入生酮狀態一段時間後,乙酰乙酸鹽就會轉換成β-丁酸鹽,因此尿液中就檢測不出乙酰乙酸鹽了。 

  • 用血糖值來判斷是否進入生酮狀態,是一種間接關係,不是直接證據。由於測量血液β-丁酸鹽濃度與呼吸丙酮濃度的機器尚未普遍,試紙也太貴,所以採用血糖值是一個不錯的變通方法。 

  • 有些人即使採行超低醣飲食,體脂也大幅減少,但是尿液中還是不會出現酮體,因為這些人能進一步把酮體燃燒掉。

  • 越嚴格的生酮飲食,酮體的量不一定就越高,因為有些人善於代謝酮體,能進一步把酮體燃燒掉,所以血液中的酮體不會積留太多,尿液中也不會出現太多酮體。

【胰島素與酮體】

  • 20世紀初,碳水化合物被稱為抗生酮因子”(the anti-ketogenic factor),因為葡萄糖會升高胰島素,胰島素一旦升高了,酮體的製造就會被迫關閉。三大營養素中,胰島素指數分別是:葡萄糖=100%,蛋白質=56%,脂肪=10% 

  • 胰島素的作用是儲存,當胰島素濃度很高時,能源會輸入到細胞內儲存,反之,當胰島素很低時,能源會從細胞內輸出到血液。所以,生酮的流程是:血糖降低→胰島素降低→輸出指令下達→肝臟分解肝醣,輸出葡萄糖,脂肪細胞釋出脂肪酸→肝醣庫存耗盡,葡萄糖缺乏補充的來源→脂肪酸成為主要的輸出燃料→脂肪酸送往肝臟分解成酮體→酮體大增。所以,生酮的3大前 提:
    1.血糖降低
    2.胰島素降低
    3.肝醣減少

【外源酮體VS內源酮體】

  • 體脂產生的是內源性酮體,中鏈脂肪酸產生的是外源性酮體,內源的酮體身體可以控制得剛剛好,不會升高胰島素,相反地,外源的酮體,會擠掉內源酮體的產量,如果外源酮體過量,導致血液總能量超標,身體還是會增加胰島素分泌來把過剩的能源儲存起來。

  • 胰島素升高→酮體停產
    酮體過量→升高胰島素

【酸鹼中和】

  • 不管是內酮或外酮,酮酸畢竟還是酸性代謝物,所以實施低醣或生酮飲食或直接攝取外酮,最好補充足夠的鹼性物質,例如:蔬菜、鹼性礦物質補充劑(鎂、鈣、鈉、鉀 、鋅),來中和這些酸性代謝物,以免身體庫存的鹼性礦物質被掏空了。

【吃藥與酮體】

  • 胰島素可以把血糖搬到肝臟儲存,如果吃藥傷到肝臟,血糖就無法儲存在肝臟,於是血糖升高,胰島素也跟著升高,胰島素升高了,酮體的製造就被關閉了。 

【醣類會打破斷食的生酮狀態】

  • 醣類會打破斷食時的生酮狀態。只要攝入7.5的葡萄糖,約2茶匙的糖或一小口的含糖飲料,生酮狀態特有的Beta-hydroxybutyrateacetoacetate就會迅速消失無蹤。(參考圖表)

【尿酸與生酮飲食】

  • 蛋白質分解會產生普林(purine),普林分解會產生尿酸,而痛風發生處的沉澱物正是尿酸的結晶,所以大家都誤認為高蛋白質食物容易導致痛風,事實上,1984Irving Fox早就發現低普林飲食對痛風是無效的。一般人害怕生酮飲食的原因之一就是蛋白質含量太高,撇開蛋白質與痛風的低關聯性不說,真正的生酮飲食是超低醣、中低蛋白、高脂肪的飲食。它是高脂飲食,並不是高蛋白飲食。

  • 雖然生酮飲食不是高蛋白飲食,但是通常第一次進入生酮狀態的人,尿酸還是會有升高的現象,只是不用擔心,4~8周後就會恢復正常。 

  • 酮體與尿酸互相競爭分解酵素 ,酮體競爭勝利,尿酸就無法完全分解排出。

  • 尿酸的追蹤方向:
    1.
    外酮是否攝取太多?內酮的產量會剛剛好,外酮的產量容易過量 ,搶走分解尿酸的酵素。
    2.果糖是否攝取過多?細菌會分解果糖,產生尿酸。果糖的其中一個代謝產物是乳酸,乳酸會跟尿酸競爭排泄途徑,導致尿酸積留體內,形成痛風。
    3.酒精是否攝取過多?

學術夜總會

  • 增加尿酸的因素:
    1.肌苷(Inosine,富含於肝臟、魚類等食物中。)
    2.鋅
    2.高蛋白飲食(動物性食物)
    3.果糖
    4.利尿劑
    5.酒精
    6.甲狀腺低下
    7.肥胖
    8.基因
    9.性荷爾蒙
    10.年紀
    11.生酮飲食
    12.高鈉飲食
    13癌症化療、腫瘤溶解症候群(Tumor lysis syndrome)
    14.慢性鉛中毒
    15.Niacin
    16.免疫抑制劑

  • 減少尿酸的因素:
    1.奶製品與鈣
    2.雌激素(難怪男性痛風機率較高)

  • 男性比較容易受到食物的影響而引發尿酸。

  • 儘管尿酸太多或太少都會造成問題,太少無法減輕氧化壓力,太多引起發炎反應。以下是尿酸的一些相關資料:
    1.尿酸在血漿中會表現抗氧化劑(anti-oxidant)的特性,但是在細胞內卻表現親氧化劑(pro-oxidant)的特性。
    2.尿酸的分子結構很像咖啡因,具有振奮的作用。
    3.尿酸與長壽 、智商有關聯。
    4.多發性硬化症、巴金森、阿茲海默症、亨丁頓舞蹈症的人尿酸都偏低。
    5.尿酸可以保護神經免於麩胺酸鹽毒性造成的神經退化。
    6.尿酸太多會引起發炎反應、痛風、腎結石 、糖尿病、高血壓、慢性腎臟病、代謝症候群。
    7.很多疾病會伴隨高尿酸,例如:尼氏乃罕症候群(Lesch-Nyhan Syndrome)、糖尿病、唐氏症、勃起障礙、牛皮癬等。
    8.尿酸會跟鐵結合,不利於貧血者。
    9.副甲狀腺素會增加尿酸。
    10.尿酸過高會增加骨折的機率。








  • 請參考→
    https://selfhacked.com/blog/uric-acid-correlated-iq-productivity-lifespan-likely-causal/
    https://selfhacked.com/blog/high-uric-acid/
    https://selfhacked.com/blog/low-uric-acid-causes-genetics-associated-disease-and-fixes/

 

【奶類與生酮飲食】

  • 牛奶與軟起司含有太高的乳糖,不適合納入生酮飲食。

  • 硬起司含太多蛋白質,不但會升高胰島素,而且會增加IGF-1,促進癌細胞生長。

  • 硬起司只能當點綴品,例如:沙拉只能撒8克的帕馬森起司,而且最好再淋一些油來提高脂肪的比例。

  • 高脂的乳製品,例如奶油與鮮奶油,蛋白質含量較少,而且還可以進一步提煉成蛋白質幾乎等於零的酥油。但是要注意的是這些高脂乳製品,不管是來自工廠飼養的牛或是有機牧場的快樂牛,都含有雌激素的代謝物。這對罹患荷爾蒙敏感型腫瘤的患者是相當不利的!

  • 克菲爾酸奶(kefir)或一般優格(yogurt)含有較多的醣類,必須擠乾濾掉乳清,而且只能少量攝取。

【生酮飲食與肌肉生長】

  • 傳統觀念認為,肌肉的生長不可或缺的營養素是肝糖與胺基酸,所以必須攝取澱粉與蛋白質。但是根據Jacob Wilson的最新研究顯示,有或沒有醣類,重量訓練都會長肌肉。換句話說,有無醣類,蛋白質一樣能合成肌肉。

  • 研究發現,經過6周的低醣生酮飲食(5%醣類),肌肉的肝醣量不變,沒有減少。

  • 原理是:胺基酸中的丙胺酸(alanine)可以快速轉換成葡萄糖(糖質新生),再合成為肝醣提供肌肉生長所需 。

【生酮飲食與肌肉流失】

  • 生酮飲食不會犧牲肌肉來進行糖質新生。

  • 實驗分成二組,一組是一周7天都實施生酮飲食,另一組是周一到週五實施生酮飲食,周末2天補充澱粉。結果發現,二組體重都有減輕,不同的是,一周7天生酮飲食所減的體重是體脂,肌肉沒有減少,而一周5天生酮飲食所減的體重是肌肉居多,體脂只減少一點點。結論是:生酮飲食不會犧牲肌肉來進行糖質新生,提高醣類反而會抑制生酮適應狀態,最後導致肌肉流失。

  • 目前各項實驗的結論傾向:極低醣飲食只要攝取足的蛋白質是不會造成肌肉流失的問題。

【生酮飲食與運動表現】

  • 實施生酮飲食一周後,運動表現會 較差一些,大約6周(或更長的時間)以後,才會慢慢恢復原來的水平,所以,一般都認為生酮適應期是幾周到幾月的時間,但是,從優秀運動員的實驗中發現,生酮適應一直都在進行,有的甚至超過一年。

  • 生酮適應後的生理變化是:粒線體數目增加、血酮增加、酮體的吸收與利用能力增強(細胞層級)。

【嬰兒與生酮】

  • 嬰兒出生時是處於生酮狀態,他們使用酮體的速率是成人的5~40倍。

  • Volek認為,長大後燃脂能力的減弱是因為採用了高醣飲食,是人為的改變,不是人類長大後就應該採用非生酮飲食。

【膽固醇升高】

【生酮的原理】

  • 生酮狀態的前提是缺乏葡萄糖(不是靠增加膳食脂肪),身體被迫代謝脂肪來當能量。要打造葡萄糖缺乏的環境,有3種方法:

    1.  直接方式:限制醣類。

    2.  間接方式:減少蛋白質。因為過多的蛋白質會轉換成大量葡萄糖,無法製造缺乏葡萄糖的前提條件。

    3.  少食或斷食。斷食經過一段時間後,體內的葡萄糖、肝醣就會用光,於是身體被迫分解脂肪成酮體來當主要能源,另外,身體還會分解肌肉中的蛋白質來轉換成葡萄糖,以供應少數只能使用葡萄糖的細胞。 

【南雲吉則經驗】

  • 日本醫師南雲吉則是利用 【一日一餐+少食】來進入生酮狀態,他不是採用低醣、低蛋白、高脂的飲食法。 

  • 南雲吉則的具體做法是:每天只吃晚餐,食量超少,通常是一小碟菜、一小碗湯,再加上少量主食,吃完馬上睡覺(他說馬上睡覺可以讓食物轉換成脂肪)。由於食量極少,身體會盡量儲存脂肪,所以第二天起床後,他就靠燃燒脂肪度日。 

【生酮與新陳代謝】

  • 低卡飲食會讓身體進入飢餓模式而調低新陳代謝率,但是真正的飢餓(斷食、胃縮小手術)與生酮飲食都不會讓身體進入飢餓模式,也不會導致新陳代謝率下降。

【總結】

  • 可以測試早上的空腹血糖,如果落在55~75之間,就代表你已經進入生酮狀態。你不需要很高的血糖來維生,你大宗是靠酮體維生,你只需要生產少量的葡葡糖來供應少數依賴靠葡萄糖維生的細胞(粒線體數目很少或完全缺乏的細胞),例如: 紅血球、眼角膜、視網膜、水晶體、白血球、睪丸、腎臟內皮細胞。 

  • 如果是高於75,但是落於75~83之間,你也可能處於生酮狀態,只是不太確定而已。正常人的血糖是83,所以空腹血糖高於83者,確定已經脫離生酮狀態了,必須再調整飲食。大致上都是在調整蛋白質的量,這是生酮飲食的盲區,因為多餘的蛋白質會轉成葡萄糖。另外就是總卡路里,其中的一個盲區是脂肪攝取量。即使醣類與蛋白質都控制很好,但是脂肪攝取過量,造成總卡路里過高,也是會脫離生酮狀態。為什麼?當血液總能量過多時,身體會設法把過剩能量儲存起來,於是分泌胰島素來把營養素送進細胞,而胰島素與酮體是呈相反關係,胰島素上升,酮體就下降,所以整個流程是:總能量過高→胰島素上升→關閉脂肪燃燒→酮體下降。 

  • 我個人的總結是,生酮飲食的輸入條件(input)5個,如果正確輸入,就能得到正確輸出(output)
    1.
    超低醣類(穀類、水果、根莖類都禁吃,只吃葉菜類與香料。):這是最重要的關鍵!
    2.
    低蛋白(1公克蛋白質/每日每公斤體重)
    3.
    高脂(要占總卡路里的80%以上)
    中短鏈脂肪酸尤佳,例如:奶油、椰子油、C8這是輔助方法,幫助身體對抗飢餓,順利度過時應期。
    4.
    控制總卡路里(這個要自己去抓出大概)
    5.
    縮小進食窗口,6小時之內完成所有餐飲,其他時間禁食。
    (我個人的作法是一日一餐,如果你非吃2餐不可,我的建議是過午不食。) 

參考資料:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sBjnWfT8HbQ

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A-_UY-WnH1k

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UjPgK7gWJeM

http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2013/06/30/dagostino-cancer-research.aspx

Cancer as a Metabolic Desease: On the Origin, Management, and Prevention of Cancer--Thomas Seyfried

KETO CLARITY--Jimmy Moore & Eric Westman 


【FB貼文】

  • 生酮飲食的關鍵是減少醣類,不是增加脂肪攝取量,只要醣類減少,身體一定被迫分解脂肪,生產酮體來當能源(生酮=生產酮體),但是如果你攝取了大量膳食脂肪,身體就會優先燃燒這些膳食脂肪,燒完了才輪到燃燒體脂,所以想要減重的人除了減少醣類之外,還要控制膳食脂肪的攝取量。
    膳食脂肪的用意是幫助身體暫時止飢,順利度過低醣飲食的適應期。膳食脂肪只是配角,低醣才是主角!
    不要妄想用脂肪去作弊,以為攝取了高醣,再用更高的脂肪去維持生酮的比例就能維持生酮狀態。很對不起!醣類一提高,生酮狀態就結束了,多餘的脂肪都會送進體脂倉庫妥善保管。
    最後,我們還要考慮一個配角,那就是蛋白質。因為蛋白質可以進行糖質新生轉換成葡萄糖(80%的糖質新生是由蛋白質轉化的),所以太多蛋白質會使葡萄糖的量降不下來。

【答覆網友】

  • 其實,我的生酮飲食觀念是偏向於斷食,而不是刻意增加膳食脂肪來達成高脂的比例。因為油脂的缺口可以由體脂自動填補,另外也可以由過剩的醣類與蛋白質去轉換成脂肪來填補。只要空腹時間夠長,生酮狀態是水到渠成,自然達成。我認為斷食才是真正適合自己的生酮飲食,斷食時的三大營養素比例是因人而異的,身體視需要而自動調節成最佳比例,不是人為猜測的比例。所以,補充外酮,我都稱之為假生酮。

  • 不管你是採取啥飲食,只要空腹時間夠長,肝醣與蛋白質的庫存減少到一定程度,身體就會切換到燃燒體脂為主的模式,自動進入所謂的生酮狀態。肝醣有庫存,大家都知道,蛋白質有庫存,很多人不知道,當我們吃了一頓蛋白餐,蛋白質會暫存在小腸(血液中也暫存了一些),然後慢慢釋放達8小時之久,而蛋白質的釋放意味著糖質新生還很旺盛,葡萄糖的供應量還很多,身體不會切換成燃脂為主的生酮模式,一定要等到肝醣與蛋白質的庫存都差不多快用完了,生酮的量才會大增,有別於平常的少量生酮。生酮是一直在進行的,身體是混合引擎,葡萄糖與酮體是同時存在的,差別是量的多寡而已,所謂生酮狀態都是指酮體占大宗的能源狀態,不是完全沒有葡萄糖,同理,非生酮狀態也不是完全都是燃燒葡萄糖,酮體還是存在,量很少而已。

  • 生酮關鍵是胰島素濃度,路線有二:
    1.低醣+低蛋白,油脂不是重點。這條路線的胰島素上升不高,很快就能降下來,進入燃燒模式,燃燒的原料剛開始是肝醣居多,由於肝醣不多,很快就輪到燃燒脂肪,進入生酮狀態。脂肪的來源有二種,膳食脂肪與體脂,身體會優先燃燒膳食脂肪,最後才燃燒體脂。希望燃燒體脂的人就不能無限制攝取膳食油脂。
    2.不限制醣與蛋白質,走這條路線就要延長空腹時間來降低胰島素。一開始,醣類與蛋白質太多,胰島素上升太多,身體進入儲存模式,醣類先儲存為肝醣,過剩的醣轉與蛋白質再轉換成體脂儲存,接著一定要延長空腹,直到胰島素下降了,身體再去燃燒這些儲存的燃料。空腹時間一定要夠長,甚至需要斷食才能燃燒到體脂,因為這條路線有幾個障礙:1.胰島素太高,2.肝醣儲存太多,所以需要較長的時間讓胰島素降下來,同時也需要較長的時間去燒掉肝醣,等到肝醣減少到相當的量,身體才會大宗燃燒脂肪,進入生酮狀態。所以這條路線比較慢。至於那些三餐+點心的高糖高蛋白飲食者,是 很難生酮的。

  • 防彈、MCT、C8作為中繼站或治療某些腦部疾病是OK的,最後還是要乖乖走上斷食之路,因為過多的外酮除了卡位之外,還會刺激胰島素,進行儲存工作。你不燒體脂,你偏要燒MCT、C8,你的體脂不會減少,或是減少的不夠多,體脂包括內臟脂肪,於是內臟脂肪依舊在,內臟機能依舊減弱,還有,脂肪也是荷爾蒙器官,你不減體脂,你如何改善脂肪相關的荷爾蒙狀態?


  • 血糖與酮體的關係:(參考圖表)
    當血糖高於6.0 mmol/L (108mg/dL)時,酮體幾乎是不存在的。

     

  • 最佳酮體濃度分布圖:(參考圖表)


【血酮濃度的問題】

  • 血酮濃度只能當參考,還要再深入測量酮體的產量與代謝量。

  • 酮體是脂肪代謝的中間產物,最後會變成二氧化碳與水。同樣地,葡萄糖是醣類代謝的中間產物,最後也會變成二氧化碳與水。

  • 血酮濃度只是代表血酮在血液的濃度,無法告訴我們明確的脂肪燃燒程度。血酮就好像倉庫的庫存,庫存的多寡,不是只看生產多少或銷售多少,而是看二者的互動。所以,血酮濃度有可能是以下情形的結果:
    1.生產多,燃燒多。
    2.生產多,燃燒少。
    3.生產少,燃燒多。
    4.生產少,燃燒少。


生酮飲食與癌症

利用生酮飲食來治癌症,儘管理論上很合邏輯,臨床結果卻是讓人失望的!大家可以參考《Dr. Gonzalez dismantles the ketogenic diet for cancer》這篇專文。我個人的讀後心得如下: 

Dr. Gonzalez排除了生酮飲食的治癌效果。因為他的好友--減肥權威阿金博士--已經實驗過了,無效!雖然生酮飲食治癌的理論非常合理、非常吸引人,但是應用在臨床上卻是失敗的!而且很多抗癌成功者都是採用高醣飲食。這些存活的實例否決了癌細胞只能靠葡萄糖維生的理論。(Dr. Kelley認為癌症是缺乏胰臟蛋白質分解酵素所造成的,所以他會限制癌症患者的蛋白質攝取量,尤其是煮熟的動物性蛋白質,以免耗盡胰臟的蛋白質分解酵素。這些蛋白質分解酵素可以分解癌細胞的偽裝外衣,讓免疫細胞能夠辨識癌細胞,進而消滅癌細胞。) 

Dr. Gonzalez推論癌細胞可能比我們想像的還要強韌,他們可能具有適應無糖環境的能力,例如:分解肌肉中的蛋白質來當食物(麩醯胺酸Glutamine) 

Dr. Gonzalez的派別是採用三足鼎立的方法治癌(飲食+酵素+咖啡灌腸),他認為要徹底殺死癌細胞必須殺死癌細胞的元祖--癌幹細胞。如果只是殺死它的子孫而不根除元祖,就會出現腫瘤縮小了但是癌細胞依然存在,而且源源不斷,最後還是轉移出去,造成死亡。 

唉!前幾天我還很高興地貼出【生酮飲食+限制卡路里+高壓氧】的癌症新療法,想不到生酮飲食與高壓氧都被Dr. Gonzalez否決了! 

臨床經驗是很現實的,失敗就是失敗,原因不明,有待日後科學家去解開謎底! 

雖然阿金博士的生酮飲食治癌失敗,但是Cantin女士採用她自創的生酮飲食卻是成功地治好她自己的乳癌,這又怎麼解釋?或許誠如Cantin女士所說的:阿金版生酮飲食沒有排除食物中的過敏原與毒素,例如:穀類、乳製品、紅肉、基因改良食物、重金屬、含氯與氟的自來水、加工食品、MSG(味精)...等。 

為何排除食物中的過敏原與毒素會成為治癌成功的關鍵因素呢?須知一個健康的人是不會罹癌的,只有當免疫力破產了才可能罹癌!而排除過敏原與毒素,恰好可以減輕免疫負擔,讓身體保留較多的免疫力去打擊癌細胞!這是非常重要的一環!很多治癌專家使盡各種辦法去消滅癌細胞,例如:手術、化療、電療、熱療、食療、酵素療法、週波療法、木馬伏兵療法….等五花八門,這些療法確實能減少癌細胞,甚至完全消滅癌細胞,但是只要過敏原與毒素沒有清除,身體的免疫力就不可能充足癌細胞就有機會反撲,就好像警力不足,壞人會趁機作亂一樣。這也是癌症容易復發的原因之一! 

參考資料

http://www.chrisbeatcancer.com/dr-gonzalez-dismantles-ketogenic-diet-for-cancer/ 

【後記】

這篇文章裡,談了很多癌症的療法,Dr. Gonzalez說出了他的看法,很值得大家參考!其中採用大量胰臟酵素治癌,更是Dr. Gonzalez的絕活! 

【小典故】

Dr. Gonzalez的療法是承襲自Dr. KelleyDr. Kelley不是醫生,他是牙醫師。年輕時他罹患胰臟癌,罹癌過程中常常消化不良,於是他服用非常大量的胰臟酵素來幫助消化,卻無意中發現胰臟酵素可以讓腫瘤變小變軟,但是腫瘤縮小了,人反而更虛弱,頭暈頭痛,極度不舒服,迫使他必須中斷服用胰臟酵素。可是停用胰臟酵素後,腫瘤馬上又變大變硬。他百思不解,後來他靈機一動,會不會是癌細胞分解後的毒素排不出來,反而毒害了自己?於是他積極尋找排毒法,他翻遍了醫典,最後在醫師手冊上看到了咖啡灌腸排毒法,於是他在酵素療法的基礎下加入咖啡灌腸,最後才救回了自己的小命!後來他就用這套三足鼎立的治癌法(飲食+酵素+咖啡灌腸)去幫助其他癌患,居然也有效!於是一傳十,十傳百,展開了他傳奇的治癌生涯! 


生酮飲食的療效

(請參考Jimmy Moore’s Keto Clarity 》書中的第131718三章)

Solid science (chapter 16)
Epilepsy
Diabetes mellitus
Weight loss
Polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS)
Irritable bowel syndrome (IBS)
GERD and heartburn
Non-alcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD)
Good evidence (chapter 17)

Alzheimer’s disease

Parkinson’s disease

Dementia

Schizophrenia, bipolar and other mental illnesses

Narcolepsy and other sleep disorders

Exercise performance

Emerging areas (chapter 18)

Cancer

Fibromyalgia

Chronic pain

Migraines

Traumatic brain injury

Stroke

Gum disease and tooth decay

Acne

Eyesight

Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS)

Multiple sclerosis (MS) and Huntington’s disease

Aging

Kidney disease

Restless leg syndrome (RLS)

Arthritis

Alopecia and hair loss

GLUT1 deficiency syndrome

 

生酮食物
fats and oils

butter

coconut oil

olive oil

fish oil

flax seed oil

lard

bacon grease

 

nuts, seeds & legumes

Brazil nuts

pecan nuts

peanuts

Macadamia nuts

sunflower seeds

coconut milk

pine nuts

almonds

coconut meat

almond butter

pumpkin seeds

almonds

pistachio nuts

 

fruit

avocado

olives

 

dairy and egg

egg yolk

whole egg

cream

cream cheese

goat cheese

cheddar cheese

Monterey cheese

Camembert

Muenster cheese

Colby cheese

brie

blue cheese

Edam

Gruyere

parmesan cheese

feta cheese

mozzarella cheese

gouda

Provolone

Monterey cheese

ricotta cheese

cottage cheese

 

animal products & fish

polish sausage

link sausage

chorizo

frankfurter

bratwurst

beef sausage

duck

knackwurst

bacon

bologna

herring

ground lamb

chicken

chuck eye steak

sardines

turkey

chicken liver

anchovy

salmon

ham

carp

trout

clam

catfish

shrimp

oyster

squid

lobster

cod

haddock

 

vegetables

turnip greens

mustard greens

coriander

spinach

artichokes

mushrooms

chives

lettuce

alfalfa seeds

sauerkraut

cauliflower

asparagus

 


以下是署名Jhe JiaFB分享內容

811 10:44· https://www.facebook.com/rsrc.php/v2/yB/r/-pz5JhcNQ9P.png

亞培 輔理善越佳型 血糖血酮兩用機 使用心得分享
http://www.abbott-freestyle.com.tw/product02.asp

當初購買的目的,是為了量化觀察血糖和血酮之間的變化,另一方面證明自己的努力跟虛榮心。
這一台血糖機是血糖跟血酮兩用的,一般醫療用品只賣血糖用的,亞培這台比較符合我的需求,血糖血酮兩用機選擇上也不多,要去哪找醫療用品店,醫院附近一定有,建議找連鎖的比較有保障,因為衛福部的關係,這種東西網路上不准賣,所以價錢都要實際打電話問,我是在"維康醫療用品"買的,第一次買都要買整組的(血糖機、酒精棉50p、血糖試紙50p、取血針50p),售價3600元會員可以打9折是3240元,血糖試紙50p會員900元、血酮試紙10p會員720(血酮試紙常常缺貨要訂)
維康門市查詢
http://www.wellcare.com.tw/wellindex/03map.htm
使用教學影片
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O9B3GZbm1aI&feature=youtu.be
使用心得
1.
採血針務必裝到底,不然採血會超痛的。
2.
取血部位建議參考教學影片,手指兩側有血管,避免取血不足浪費試紙,試紙如果沒有取血足夠或分兩次取血都會失準。
3.
同部位取血太多次,血小板會凝結造成取血困難或不足。
4.
取血時建議腦袋放空,用力一壓採血筆,避免心理壓力,習慣取血後就可以克服了。因為我腦包一開始沒把取血針裝到底,取血筆打下去超痛的,感覺被人拿針從手指頭用力戳了一下,千萬不要跟我一樣腦包了。

 

 

 


The Ketogenic Diet – An Overview

Posted by: Gabriela Segura, MD

The Ketogenic Diet – An Overview

Ketosis is an often misunderstood subject. Its presence is thought to be equal to starvation or a warning sign of something going wrong in your metabolism. But nothing could be farther from the truth, except if you are an ill-treated type 1 diabetic person.[1] Ketones – contrary to popular belief and myth – are a much needed and essential healing energy source in our cells that comes from the normal metabolism of fat.

The entire body uses ketones in a more safe and effective way than the energy source coming from carbohydrates – sugar AKA glucose. Our bodies will produce ketones if we eat a diet devoid of carbs or a low carb diet (less than 60 grams of carbs per day).[2] By eating a very low carb diet or no carbs at all (like a caveman) we become keto-adapted.

In fact, what is known today as the ketogenic diet was the number one treatment for epilepsy until Big Pharma arrived with its dangerous cocktails of anti-epileptic drugs. It took several decades before we heard again about this diet, thanks in part to a parent who demanded it for his 20-month-old boy with severe seizures. The boy’s father had to find out about the ketogenic diet in a library as it was never mentioned as an option by his neurologist. After only 4 days on the diet, his seizures stopped and never returned.[3] The Charlie Foundation was born after the kid’s name and his successful recovery, but nowadays the ketogenic diet is available to the entire world and it’s spreading by word of mouth thanks to its healing effects.

http://neurorexia.files.wordpress.com/2013/03/tumblr_ls6vtiia7t1qeg47lo1_500.jpg?w=525

It is not only used as a healthy lifestyle, it is also used for conditions such as infantile spasms, epilepsy, autism, brain tumors, Alzheimer’s disease, Lou Gehrig’s disease, depression, stroke, head trauma, Parkinson’s disease, migraine, sleep disorders, schizophrenia, anxiety, ADHD, irritability, polycystic ovarian disease, irritable bowel syndrome, gastroesophageal reflux, obesity, cardiovascular disease, acne, type 2 diabetes, tremors, respiratory failure and virtually every neurological problem but also cancer, and conditions were tissues need to recover after a loss of oxygen.[4]

Our body organs and tissues work much better when they use ketones as a source of fuel, including the brain, heart and the core of our kidneys. If you ever had a chance to see a heart working in real time, you might have noticed the thick fatty tissue that surrounds it. In fact, heart surgeons get to see this every day. A happy beating heart is one that is surrounded by layers of healthy fat. Both the heart and the brain run at least 25% more efficiently on ketones than on blood sugar.

Ketones are the ideal fuel for our bodies unlike glucose – which is damaging, less stable, more excitatory and in fact shortens your life span. Ketones are non-glycating, which is to say, they don’t have a caramelizing aging effect on your body. A healthy ketosis also helps starve cancer cells as they are unable to use ketones for fuel, relying on glucose alone for their growth. [5]The energy producing factories of our cells – the mitochondria – work much better on a ketogenic diet as they are able to increase energy levels on a stable, long-burning, efficient, and steady way. Not only that, a ketogenic diet induces epigenetic changes[6] which increases the energetic output of our mitochondria, reduces the production of damaging free radicals, and favors the production of GABA – a major inhibitory brain chemical. GABA has an essential relaxing influence and its favored production by ketosis also reduces the toxic effects of excitatory pathways in our brains. Furthermore, recent data suggests that ketosis alleviates pain other than having an overall anti-inflammatory effect. [7]

The ketogenic diet acts on multiple levels at once, something that no drug has been able to mimic. This is because mitochondria is specifically designed to use fat for energy. When our mitochondria uses fat as an energetic source, its toxic load is decreased, expression of energy producing genes are increased, its energetic output is increased, and the load of inflammatory energetic-end-products is decreased.

The key of these miraculous healing effects relies in the fact that fat metabolism and its generation of ketone bodies (beta-hydroxybutyrate and acetoacetate) by the liver can only occur within the mitochondrion, leaving chemicals within the cell but outside the mitochondria readily available to stimulate powerful anti-inflammatory antioxidants.  The status of our mitochondria is the ultimate key for optimal health and while it is true that some of us might need extra support in the form of nutritional supplementation to heal these much needed energy factories, the diet still remains the ultimate key for a proper balance.

Our modern world’s staple energetic source is sugar which needs to be processed first in the cell soup before it can be passed into the energy factory of the cell- the mitochondrion. Energy sources from fat don’t require this processing; it goes directly into the mitochondria for energetic uses.  That is, it is more complicated to create energy out of sugar than out of fat. As Christian B. Allan, PhD and Wolfgang Lutz, MD said in their book Life Without Bread:

Carbohydrates are not required to obtain energy. Fat supplies more energy than a comparable amount of carbohydrate, and low-carbohydrate diets tend to make your system of producing energy more efficient. Furthermore, many organs prefer fat for energy.

The fact is you get MORE energy per molecule of fat than sugar. How many chronic and autoimmune diseases have an energy deficit component?  How about chronic fatigue?  Fibromyalgia?  Rheumatoid Arthritis?  Multiple Sclerosis? Cancer? Back to Allan and Lutz:

Mitochondria are the power plants of the cell. Because they produce most of the energy in the body, the amount of energy available is based on how well the mitochondria are working. Whenever you think of energy, think of all those mitochondria churning out ATP to make the entire body function correctly. The amount of mitochondria in each cell varies, but up to 50 percent of the total cell volume can be mitochondria. When you get tired, don’t just assume you need more carbohydrates; instead, think in terms of how you can maximize your mitochondrial energy production…

If you could shrink to a small enough size to get inside the mitochondria, what would you discover? The first thing you’d learn is that the mitochondria are primarily designed to use fat for energy!

In short, let fat be thy medicine and medicine be thy fat!

You will think that with all of this information we would see ketogenic diets recommended right and left by our health care providers, but alas, that is not the case. Mainstream nutritionists recommend carbohydrates AKA sugar as the main staple of our diets. The problem with this (and there are several of them) is that in the presence of a high carb diet we are unable to produce ketones from the metabolism of fats, thus, depriving ours bodies from much healing ketone production.  The fact that we live in a world which uses glucose as a primary fuel means that we eat a very non healing food in more ways than one.

I have been doing the low carb diet for about a week and a half now and I must say, I am really starting to feel amazing!!!  The first few days my head hurt, I felt lethargic, and my legs felt so heavy. But after I got past that, I have so much energy. I don’t get tired anymore around 3pm. The best part is, I am not constantly thinking and obsessing about food. I feel a real sense of inner calm. My skin looks better, my hair looks better too.
I have been having bacon and eggs for breakfast, a pork chop or other piece of meat for lunch, and usually some pork and sometimes some green beans for dinner. I have also lost some weight!  Woo hoo!!! -Angela, United States. Sott.net forum.

We have been on a ketogenic diet for nearly three million years and it has made us human. It was the lifestyle in which our brains got nurtured and evolved. But not anymore, unless we all make an effort to reclaim this lost wisdom. Nowadays the human brain is not only shrinking, but brain atrophy is the norm as we age and get plagued with diseases such as Alzheimer’s disease, Parkinson’s disease, senile dementia and so forth.

In the mean time new research is starting to elucidate the key role of our mitochondria in the regulation of the cell cycle – the vital process by which a single celled fertilized egg develops into a mature organism, as well as the process by which hair, skin, blood cells, and some internal organs are renewed. In the complicated and highly choreographed events surrounding cell-cycle progression, mitochondria are not simple bystanders merely producing energy but instead are full-fledged participants.[8] Given the significant amount of energy needed to make all the nutrients required for cell division, it makes sense that some coordination existed. This long ignored and overlooked connection between the mitochondria and the cell cycle is something that is worthy of considerable more attention as we understand the role of diet in our bodies. We’ll have to take a closer look to this subject of ketosis, as it really holds the key to unlock our transformational pathways that will lead us to an outstanding healthy living.

Mitochondrial Dysfunction

Mitochondria are best known as the powerhouses of our cells since they produce the cell’s energy. But they also lead the genetic orchestra which regulates how every cell ages, divides, and dies. They help dictate which genes are switched on or off in every single cell of our organism. They also provide the fuel needed to make new brain connections, repair and regenerate our bodies.

Whether we are housewives, sportsmen or labor people, energy is a topic that concerns us all, every day and in every way. Our well being, behavior and ability to perform the tasks in front of us to do is our individual measure of energy. But how we derive energy from the foods that we eat?

There are many man-made myths surrounding energy production in the body and which foods supply energy. Mainstream science says that carbohydrates are what mitochondria use as fuel for energy production. This process is called oxidative metabolism because oxygen is consumed in the process. The energy produced by mitochondria is stored in a chemical “battery”, a unique molecule called adenosine triphosphate (ATP). Energy-packed ATP can then be transported throughout the cell, releasing energy on demand of specific enzymes. In addition to the fuel they produce, mitochondria also create a by-product related to oxygen called reactive oxygen species (ROS), commonly known as free radicals. But what we are not told is that mitochondria were specifically designed to use fat for energy, not carbohydrate.

Source: Christian B. Allan, PhD and Wolfgang Lutz, MD, Life Without Bread.

There are several very complicated steps in making ATP within mitochondria, but a look at 5 major parts of ATP production will be all that you need to know in order to understand how energy is created within our mitochondria and why fats are the key to optimize their function. Don’t get focused on specific names, just try to see the whole picture.

Step 1 – Transportation of Food-Based Fuel Source into the Mitochondria

Fuel must first get into the mitochondria where all the action happens. Fuel can come from carbs or it can come from fats. Fatty acids are the chemical name for fat, and medium and large sized fatty acids get into the mitochondria completely intact with the help of L-carnitine. Think of L-carnitine as a subway train that transports fatty acids into the mitochondria. L-carnitine (from the Greek word carnis means meat or flesh) is chiefly found in animal products.

Fuel coming from carbs needs to get broken down first outside the mitochondria and the product of this breakdown (pyruvate) is the one who gets transported inside the mitochondria, or it can be used to produce energy in a very inefficient way outside the mitochondria through anaerobic metabolism which produces ATP when oxygen is not present.

Step 2 – Fuel is Converted into Acetyl-CoA

When pyruvate – the product of breaking down carbs – enters the mitochondria, it first must be converted into acetyl-CoA by an enzymatic reaction.

Fatty acids that are already inside the mitochondria are broken down directly into acetyl-CoA in what is called beta-oxidation.

Acetyl-CoA is the starting point of the next step in the production of ATP inside the mitochondria.

Step 3 – Oxidation of Acetyl-CoA and the Krebs Cycle

The Krebs cycle (AKA tricarboxylic acid cycle or citric acid cycle) is the one that oxidizes the acetyl-CoA, removing thus electrons from acetyl-CoA and producing carbon dioxide as a by-product in the presence of oxygen inside the mitochondria.

Step 4 – Electrons Are Transported Through the Respiratory Chain

The electrons obtained from acetyl-CoA – which ultimately came from carbs or fats – are shuttled through many molecules as part of the electron transport chain inside the mitochondria. Some molecules are proteins, others are cofactors molecules. One of these cofactors is an important substance found mainly in animal foods and it is called coenzyme Q-10. Without it, mitochondrial energy production would be minimal. This is the same coenzyme Q10 that statins drug block producing crippling effects on people’s health. Step 4 is also where water is produced when oxygen accepts the electrons.

Step 5 – Oxidative phosphorylation

As electrons travel down the electron transport chain, they cause electrical fluctuations (or chemical gradients) between the inner and outer membrane in the mitochondria. These chemical gradients are the driving forces that produce ATP in what is called oxidative phosphorylation. Then the ATP is transported outside the mitochondria for the cell to use as energy for any of its thousands of biochemical reactions.

But why is fat better than carbs?

If there were no mitochondria, then fat metabolism for energy would be limited and not very efficient. But nature provided us during our evolution with mitochondria that specifically uses fat for energy. Fat is the fueled that animals use to travel great distances, hunt, work, and play since fat gives more packed-energy ATPs than carbs. Biochemically, it makes sense that if we are higher mammals who have mitochondria, then we need to eat fat.  Whereas carb metabolism yields 36 ATP molecules from a glucose molecule, a fat metabolism yields 48 ATP molecules from a fatty acid molecule inside the mitochondria. Fat supplies more energy for the same amount of food compared to carbs. But not only that, the burning of fat by the mitochondria – beta oxidation – produces ketone bodies that stabilizes overexcitation and oxidative stress in the brain related to all its diseases, it also causes epigenetic changes that produce healthy and energetic mitochondria and decreasing the overproduction of damaging and inflammatory free radicals among many other things!

Mitochondria regulate cellular suicide, AKA apoptosis, so that old and dysfunctional cells which need to die will do so, leaving space for new ones to come into the scene. But when mitochondria function becomes impaired and send signals that tell normal cells to die, things go wrong. For instance, the destruction of brain cells leads to every single neurodegenerative condition known including Alzheimer’s disease, Parkinson’s disease and so forth. Mitochondrial dysfunction has wide-ranging implications, as the health of the mitochondria intimately affects every single cell, tissue and organ within your body.

The catalysts for this destruction is usually uncontrolled free radical production which cause oxidative damage to tissues, fat, proteins, DNA; causing them to rust. This damage, called oxidative stress, is at the basis of oxidized cholesterol, stiff arteries (rusty pipes) and brain damage. Oxidative stress is a key player in dementia as well as autism.

We produce our own anti-oxidants to keep a check on free radical production, but these systems are easily overwhelmed by a toxic environment and a high carb diet, in other words, by today’s lifestyle and diet.

Mitochondria also have interesting characteristics which differentiate them from all other structural parts of our cells. For instance, they have their own DNA (referred as mtDNA) which is separate from the widely known DNA in the nucleus (referred as n-DNA),. Mitochondrial DNA comes for the most part from the mother line, which is why mitochondria is also considered as your feminine life force. This mtDNA is arranged in a ring configuration and it lacks a protective protein surrounding, leaving its genetic code vulnerable to free radical damage. If you don’t eat enough animal fats, you can’t build a functional mitochondrial membrane which will keep it healthy and prevent them from dying.

If you have any kind of inflammation from anywhere in your body, you damage your mitochondria. The loss of function or death of mitochondria is present in pretty much every disease. Dietary and environmental factors lead to oxidative stress and thus to mitochondrial injury as the final common pathway of diseases or illnesses.

Autism, ADHD, Parkinson’s, depression, anxiety, bipolar disease, brain aging are all linked with mitochondrial dysfunction from oxidative stress. Mitochondrial dysfunction contributes to congestive heart failure, type 2 diabetes, autoimmune disorders, aging, cancer, and other diseases.

Whereas the nDNA provides the information your cells need to code for proteins that control metabolism, repair, and structural integrity of your body, it is the mtDNA which directs the production and utilization of your life energy. A cell can still commit suicide (apoptosis) even when it has no nucleus nor nDNA.

Because of their energetic role, the cells of tissues and organs which require more energy to function are richer in mitochondrial numbers. Cells in our brains, muscles, heart, kidney and liver contain thousands of mitochondria, comprising up to 40% of the cell’s mass. According to Prof. Enzo Nisoli, a human adult possesses more than ten million billion mitochondria, making up a full 10% of the total body weight.[9] Each cell contains hundreds of mitochondria and thousands of mtDNA.

Since mtDNA is less protected than nDNA because it has no “protein” coating (histones), it is exquisitely vulnerable to injury by destabilizing molecules such as neurotoxic pesticides, herbicides, excitotoxins, heavy metals and volatile chemicals among others. This tips off the balance of free radical production to the extreme which then leads to oxidative stress damaging our mitochondria and its DNA. As a result we get overexcitation of cells and inflammation which is at the root of Parkinson’s disease and other diseases, but also mood problems and behavior problems.

Enough energy means a happy and healthy life. It also reflects in our brains with focused and sharp thinking. Lack of energy means mood problems, dementia, and slowed mental function among others. Mitochondria are intricately linked to the ability of the prefrontal cortex –our brain’s captain- to come fully online. Brain cells are loaded in mitochondria that produce the necessary energy to learn and memorize, and fire neurons harmoniously.

The sirtuin family of genes works by protecting and improving the health and function of your mitochondria.[10] They are positively influenced by a diet that is non-glycating, i.e. a low carb diet as opposed to a high carb diet which induces mitochondrial dysfunction and formation of reactive oxygen species.

Another thing that contributes to mitochondrial dysfunction is latent viral infection such as the ones of the herpes family. As I mentioned in On Viral “Junk” DNA, a DNA Enhancing Ketogenic Diet, and Cometary Kicks, most, if not all of your “junk” DNA has viral-like properties. If a pathogenic virus takes hold of our DNA or RNA, it could lead to disease or cancer.

Herpes simplex virus is a widespread human pathogen and it goes right after our mitochondrial DNA. Herpes simplex virus establishes its latency in sensory neurons, a type of cell that is highly sensitive to the pathological effects of mt DNA damage.[11] A latent viral infection might be driving the brain cell loss in neurodegenerative diseases such as Alzheimer’s disease.[12]As I speculated in Heart attacks, CFS, herpes virus infection and the vagus nerve , a latent herpes virus infection might drive more diseases than we would like to admit.

Members of the herpes virus family (i.e. cytomegalovirus and Epstein-Barr virus which most people have as latent infections!), can go after our mitochondrial DNA, causing neurodegenerative diseases by mitochondrial dysfunction. But a ketogenic diet is the one thing that would help stabilize mtDNA since mitochondria runs the best on fat fuel. As it happens, Alzheimer’s disease is the one condition where a ketogenic diet has its most potential healing effect.[4]

The role of mitochondrial dysfunction in our “modern” age maladies is a staggering one. Optimal energetic sources are essential if we are to heal from chronic ailments. It is our mitochondria which lies at the interface between the fuel from foods that come from our environment and our bodies’ energy demands. And it is a metabolism based on fat fuel, a ketone metabolism, the one which signals epigenetic changes that maximizes energetic output within our mitochondria and help us heal.

I am incredulous at how my body is responding.  I think I am totally carb intolerant.  I’ve struggled with extreme fatigue/exhaustion for so many years, even with improved sleep in a dark room that I can’t tell you how wonderful it is to wake up in the morning, get out of bed and not long to crawl back in, going through the day by will mostly.  Also chronic long-standing intestinal issues are finally resolving.  A couple of people at work have made comments to the effect that I’m a “different woman”, calmer, no more hyperness under pressure, stress seems to roll off of my back as well.  I’ve lost a little weight and although I don’t weigh myself, my clothes are definitely looser.  I’ve had the round middle for so many years I was resigned to struggling to bend over to pull my shoes on!  -Bluefyre, 56 years old, United States. Sott.net forum

 

Ketosis – Closer Look

The presence of ketones in the blood and urine, a condition known as ketosis, has always been regarded as a negative situation, related to starvation. While it is true that ketones are produced during fasting, ketones are also produced in times of plenty, but not plenty of carbohydrates since a carb metabolism suppresses ketosis. In the absence of most carbs in the diet, ketones will form from fat to supply for energy. This is true even if lots of fats and enough protein are eaten, something that is hardly a starvation condition.

As we already saw, a ketogenic diet has been proved useful in a number of diseases, especially neurological ones. Strictly speaking, a ketogenic diet is a high fat diet in which carbohydrates are either completely eliminated or nearly eliminated so that the body has the very bare minimum sources of glucose. That makes fats (fatty acids) a mandatory energetic fuel source for both the brain and other organs and tissues. If you are carb intake is high, you’ll end up storing both the fat and the carbs in your fat tissue thanks to the hormone insulin. A ketogenic diet is not a high protein diet, which as it happens, can also stimulate insulin. It is basically a diet where you rely primarily on animal foods and especially their fats.

I recently had my annual blood work done (cholesterol, etc.) During the review, my doctor said that everything looked great! He then encouraged me to continue on my great ‘low fat, high fruit and veggie diet’ that I must be following! I just smiled. Next visit I’m going to tell him about my real ‘diet’. Lol  -1984, United States. Sott.net forum.

 

Among the by-products of fat burning metabolism are the so called ketone bodies – acetoacetate, β-hydroxybutyrate and acetone – which are produced for the most part by the liver. When our bodies are running primarily on fats, large amounts of acetyl-CoA are produced which exceed the capacity of the Krebs cycle, leading to the making of these three ketone bodies within liver mitochondria. Our levels of ketone bodies in our blood go up and the brain readily uses them for energetic purposes. Ketone bodies cross the blood brain barrier very readily. Their solubility also makes them easily transportable by the blood to other organs and tissues. When ketone bodies are used as energy, they release acetyl-CoA which then goes to the Krebs cycle again to produce energy.

In children who were treated with the ketogenic diet to treat their epilepsy, it was seen that they become seizure-free even long after the diet ended, meaning that not only did the diet proved to be protective, but also it modified the activity of the disease , something that no drug has been able to do.[13] In Alzheimer’s disease, as levels of ketone bodies rise, memory improves. People’s starved brains finally receive the much needed fats they need! In fact, every single neurological disease is improved on the ketogenic diet.

The benefits of a ketogenic diet can be seen as fast as one week, developing gradually over a period of 3 weeks. There are several changes in gene expression involving metabolism, growth, development, and homeostasis among others.

The hippocampus is a region in your brain that is very vulnerable to stress which makes it lose its brain cells. The hippocampus has to do with memory, learning, and emotion. As it happens, a ketogenic diet promotes the codification of genes which creates mitochondria in the hippocampus, making more energy available. A larger mitochondrial load and more energy means more reserve to withstand much more stress.[14]

In some animal models, there is a 50% increase in the total number of mitochondria in the hippocampus, resulting in more brain ATP.[15] Other animal studies show how communication between brain cells in the hippocampus would remain smooth for 60% longer when exposed to a stressful stimulus compared to their counterparts who didn’t had a ketogenic diet.[16] This is very important since too much stress can damage the hippocampus and its capacity to retrieve information, making you “absent-minded” or “brain-scattered”, as well as affecting the ability of your prefrontal cortex to think and manage behavior.

A ketogenic diet also increases levels of the calming neurotransmitter – GABA which then serves to calm down the overexcitation which is at the base of major neurodegenerative diseases, but also anxiety and other mood problems. A ketogenic diet also increases antioxidant pathways that level the excess production of free radicals from a toxic environment. It also enhances anti-inflammatory pathways.

Ketosis also cleans our cells from proteins that act like “debris” and which contribute to aging by disrupting a proper functioning of the cell.[17] It basically does this by what is known as autophagy which preserves the health of cells and tissues by replacing outdated and damaged cellular components with fresh ones. This prevents degenerative diseases, aging, cancer, and protects you against microbial infections.A ketogenic diet not only rejuvenates you, it also makes a person much less susceptible to viruses and bacterial infections.[18] This is very relevant due to the increasing number of weird viral and bacterial infections that seem to be incoming from our upper atmosphere[19] (for more information see New Light on the Black Death: The Viral and Cosmic Connection), or due to high levels of radiation that creates more pathogenic strains (see Detoxify or Die: Natural Radiation Protection Therapies for Coping With the Fallout of the Fukushima Nuclear Meltdown). Either or, we are more vulnerable than ever due to the state of our mitochondria. But we can prepare for the worst with ketosis.

Ketone-enhanced autophagy is very important because autophagy can target viruses and bacteria that grow inside cells which are very problematical.[20] Intracellular viruses and bacteria can lead to severe mitochondrial dysfunction and ketosis remains by far our best chance against them.

Ketone bodies production through intermittent fasting and the ketogenic diet is the most promising treatment for mitochondrial dysfunction.[21]The longevity benefits seen caloric restriction research is due to the fact that our bodies shift to a fat burning metabolism within our mitochondria. With a ketogenic diet, we go into a fat burning metabolism without restricting our caloric intake.

Ketosis deals effectively with all the problems of a diet rich in carbs – the one recommended by mainstream science: anxiety, food cravings, irritability, tremors, and mood problems among others. It is a crime to discourage the consumption of a high fat diet considering that a ketogenic diet shrinks tumors on human and animal models, and enhances our brain’s resiliency against stress and toxicity.

In addition to increasing the production of our body’s natural valium – GABA – the increased production of acetyl-CoA generated from the ketone bodies also drives the Krebs cycle to increase mitochondrial NADH (reduced nicotinamide adenine nucleotide) which our body uses in over 450 vital biochemical reactions – including the cell signaling and assisting of the ongoing DNA repair. Because the ketone body beta-hydroxybutyrate is more energy rich than pyruvate, it produces more ATP. Ketosis also enhances the production of important anti-oxidants that deal with toxic elements from our environments, including glutathione.

Mitochondria from the hippocampus of ketogenic diet-fed animals are also resistant to mtDNA damage and are much less likely to commit cell suicide –apoptosis- at inappropriate times.

As Douglas C. Wallace, PhD, Director of the Center for Mitochondrial and Epigenomic Medicine says, “the ketogenic diet may act at multiple levels: It may decrease excitatory neuronal activity, increase the expression of bioenergetic genes, increase mitochondrial biogenesis and oxidative energy production, and increase mitochondrial NADPH production, thus decreasing mitochondrial oxidative stress.”[21]

Keto-adaptation results in marked changes in how we construct and maintain optimum membrane (“mem-brain”) composition, not only because of the healthy fats we provide through the diet, but also because of less free radical production and inflammatory mediators, along with more production of anti-oxidants. It is really the ideal balanced state.

Moreover, you might want to keep in mind this excerpt from Human Brain Evolution: The Influence of Freshwater and Marine Food Resources[22]:

“There are two key advantages to having ketone bodies as the main alternative fuel to glucose for the human brain. First, humans normally have significant body fat stores, so there is an abundant supply of fatty acids to make ketones. Second, using ketones to meet part of the brain’s energy requirement when food availability is intermittent frees up some glucose for other uses and greatly reduces both the risk of detrimental muscle breakdown during glucose synthesis, as well as compromised function of other cells dependent on glucose, that is, red blood cells. One interesting attribute of ketone uptake by the brain is that it is four to five times faster in newborns and infants than in adults. Hence, in a sense, the efficient use of ketones by the infant brain means that it arguably has a better fuel reserve than the adult brain. Although the role of ketones as a fuel reserve is important, in infants, they are more than just a reserve brain fuel – they are also the main substrate for brain lipid synthesis.

I have hypothesized that evolution of a greater capacity to make ketones coevolved with human brain expansion. This increasing capacity was directly linked to evolving fatty acid reserves in body fat stores during fetal and neonatal development. To both expand brain size and increase its sophistication so remarkably would have required a reliable and copious energy supply for a very long period of time, probably at least a million, if not two million, years. Initially, and up to a point, the energy needs of a somewhat larger hominin brain could be met by glucose and short – term glucose reserves such as glycogen and glucose synthesis from amino acids. As hominins slowly began to evolve larger brains after having acquired a more secure and abundant food supply, further brain expansion would have depended on evolving significant fat stores and having reliable and rapid access to the fuel in those fat stores. Fat stores were necessary but were still not sufficient without a coincident increase in the capacity for ketogenesis. This unique combination of outstanding fuel store in body fat as well as rapid and abundant availability of ketones as a brain fuel that could seamlessly replace glucose was the key fuel reserve for expanding the hominin brain, a reserve that was apparently not available to other land – based mammals, including nonhuman primates.”

It is indisputable that a ketogenic diet has protective effects in our brains. With all the evidence of its efficacy in mitochondrial dysfunction, it can be applied for all of us living in a highly stressful and toxic environment. Ketone bodies are healing bodies that helped us evolve and nowadays our mitochondria are always busted in some way or another since the odds in this toxic world are against us. Obviously, there are going to be people with such damaged mtDNA or with mutations they were born with, who can’t modify their systems (i.e. defects on L-carnitine metabolism), but even in some of those cases, they can halt or slow down further damage. Our healthy ancestors never had to deal with the levels of toxicity that we live nowadays and nevertheless, they ate optimally. Considering our current time and environment, the least we can do is eat optimally for our physiology.

The way to have healing ketone bodies circulating in our blood stream is to do a high fat, restricted carb and moderated protein diet. Coupled with intermittent fasting which will enhance the production of ketone bodies, and resistance training which will create mitochondria with healthier mtDNA, we can beat the odds against us.

What is considered nowadays a “normal diet” is actually an aberration based on the corruption of science which benefits Big Agra and Big Pharma. If we would go back in time to the days before the modern diet became normalized by corporative and agricultural interests, we will find that ketosis was the normal metabolic state. Today’s human metabolic state is aberrant. It is time to change that.

References

[1] A research member of sott.net’s forum has diabetes type 1 and is doing the ketogenic diet. On normal circumstances, diabetics (including type I) report amazing results on a low-carbohydrate diet. See Dr. Bernstein’s Diabetics Solution by Richard K. Bernstein, MD (Little, Brown and Company: 2007).

[2] It varies among each person, but the general range is between 0 and 70 grams of carbs plus moderate intake of protein, between 0.8 and 1.5 grams of protein per kg of ideal body weight. Pregnant women and children should not have their protein restricted.

[3] Ketogenic diets in seizure control and neurologic disorders by Eric Kossoff, MD, Johns Hopkins Hospital, Baltimore, Maryland. The Art and Science of Low Carbohydrate Living by Jeff S. Volek, PhD, Rd and Stephen D. Phinney, MD, PhD. Beyond Obesity, LLC , 2011.

[4]A Paoli, A Rubini, J S Volek and K A Grimaldi. Beyond weight loss: a review of the therapeutic uses of very-low-carbohydrate (ketogenic) diets. European Journal of Clinical Nutrition (2013) 67, 789–796

[5] Rainer J Klement, Ulrike Kämmerer. Is there a role for carbohydrate restriction in the treatment and prevention of cancer? Nutr Metab (Lond). Oct 26, 2011; 8: 75.

[6] If the genetic code is the hardware for life, the epigenetic code is software that determines how the hardware behaves.

[7] David N. Ruskin and Susan A. Masino, The Nervous System and Metabolic Dysregulation: Emerging Evidence Converges on Ketogenic Diet Therapy. Front Neurosci. 2012; 6: 33.

[8] Finkel T, Hwang PM. The Krebs cycle meets the cell cycle: mitochondria and the G1-S transition. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2009 Jul 21;106(29):11825-6.


[9] Matthews C.M. Nurturing your divine feminine. Proc (Bayl Univ Med Cent). 2011 July; 24(3): 248.

[10] Hipkiss AR. Energy metabolism, altered proteins, sirtuins and ageing: converging mechanisms? Biogerontology. 2008 Feb;9(1):49-55.

[11] Saffran HA, Pare JM, Corcoran JA, et al. Herpes simplex virus eliminates host mitochondrial DNA. EMBO Rep. 2007 Feb;8(2):188-93.

[12] Porcellini E, Carbone I, et al. Alzheimer’s disease gene signature says: beware of brain viral infections. Immun Ageing. 2010 Dec 14;7:16.

[13] Gasior M, Rogawski MA, Hartman AL. Neuroprotective and disease-modifying effects of the ketogenic diet. Behav Pharmacol. 2006 Sep;17(5-6):431-9.

[14] Maalouf M, Rho JM, Mattson MP. The neuroprotective properties of calorie restriction, the ketogenic diet, and ketone bodies. Brain Res Rev. 2009 Mar;59(2):293-315.

[15] Nylen K, Velazquez JL. The effects of a ketogenic diet on ATP concentrations and the number of hippocampal mitochondria in Aldh5a1(-/-) mice. Biochim Biophys Acta. 2009 Mar;1790(3):208-12.

[16] Bough K. Energy metabolism as part of the anticonvulsant mechanism of the ketogenic diet. Epilepsia. 2008 Nov;49 Suppl 8:91-3.

[17] Finn PF, Dice JF. Ketone bodies stimulate chaperone-mediated autophagy. J Biol Chem. 2005 Jul 8;280(27):25864-70.

[18] Yuk JM, Yoshimori T, Jo EK. Autophagy and bacterial infectious diseases. Exp Mol Med. 2012 Feb 29;44(2):99-108.

[19] Chandra Wickramasinghe, Milton Wainwright & Jayant Narlika. SARS – a clue to its origins? The Lancet, vol. 361, May 23, 2003, pp 1832.

[20] Yordy B, Iwasaki A. Autophagy in the control and pathogenesis of viral infection. Curr Opin Virol. 2011 Sep;1(3):196-203.

[21] Douglas C. Wallace, Weiwei Fan, and Vincent Procaccio. Mitochondrial Energetics and Therapeutics Annu Rev Pathol. 2010; 5: 297–348.

[22] Stephen Cunnane, Kathlyn Stewart.Human Brain Evolution: The Influence of Freshwater and Marine Food Resources. June 2010, Wiley-Blackwell.


【Brad Pilon的觀點】

  • 減重有二部分,一個是水重,另一個是非水分的體重。怎麼知道非水分的體重流失多少?我們可以用碳原子的流失量來換算。(水是氫+氧的組合,醣類與脂肪酸都是碳+氫+氧的組合 ,蛋白質是碳+氫+氧+氮的組合。)

  • 碳是如何排出體外?食物經過消化代謝,最終產物之一是二氧化碳,我們就是靠呼吸排出二氧化碳。排出越多,代表非水分的體重減少越多,這就是減重最樂意看到的結果。

  • 平均而言,碳水化合物的碳重量大約是40%,脂肪酸的碳重量大約是78%。

  • 生酮狀態下,我們並沒有呼出較多的二氧化碳,尿液排出的酮體也微乎極微。那麼,生酮飲食是怎麼減重的?比較其他飲食法,生酮飲食的碳原子出貨量相差不大,那麼我們就來清查它的進貨量。例如:同樣是吃進2000大卡,如果是吃碳水化合物,我們會吃進200克的碳原子(2000÷4×40%=200),但是如果是吃脂肪酸,我們只會吃進175克的碳(2000÷9×78%=173)。這就是高脂的生酮飲食殊勝之處:吃進的碳原子比較少。

原信件內容:

Ketogenic Diets or ‘Keto-diets’ are becoming popular... again.

This is not a new idea or trend. It was very popular in 2009, and back in 1996 (I’m starting to think diets have a twelve to fifteen year cycle)

Ketogenic diets are based on the idea of Ketosis - Ketosis is a state you body enters when you quickly move into burning predominately fat as a fuel.

When fatty acid oxidation is ramped up quickly, your liver can’t keep up and some of the fatty acids are ‘incompletely burned’ leaving ketones as a biproduct.

【Carbon Explanation: Remember that Fatty Acids are long chains of Carbon, and when we are using fat as a fuel we are simply cutting a carbon off the chain and then move that carbon out of our bodies through our breath as carbon dioxide. When our needs outweigh the speed we can ‘cut’ these carbons, we get lazy and start cutting at every third or fourth carbon, creating carbon ‘fragments’ called ketones.】

Luckily we can easily use these ketones as a fuel. In fact, ketones become the preferred fuel in many tissues, especially your brain.

【Carbon Explanation: We are still able to break ketones down to create carbon dioxide which we then exhale.】

You start to enter Ketosis somewhere between 16 and 20 hours of fasting, and it continues to increase the longer you fast. Then after about three weeks, your body is fully adapted to fat and you go back to burning predominantly fat as a fuel.

In summary - Ketones are produced when fatty acids are being used as a fuel at a rate that is quicker then we can handle, leading to the incomplete breakdown of fatty acids and the creation of ketones. Ketosis is temporary as we eventually are able to increase our ability to fully use Fatty Acids as a fuel source, Ketosis typically lasts two to three weeks, depending on the person.

Ketosis is a Hallmark of prolonged fasting. However, since most people don’t want to fast, there are also Ketogenic diets based on consuming mostly Fat.

And here is the focus of this email - Ketogenic Diets and their use for weight loss.

Ketogenic diets are Low carb diets (usually under 50 grams per day), that are also low (ish) protein diets - typically recommending under 100 grams of protein, the rest of the diet is Fat.

Upwards of 70% of your daily calories come from Fat when you are on a Ketogenic Diet.

People either Love or Hate ketogenic diets.

Our main concern is - Do they somehow create BETTER or MORE fat loss?

For weight loss we know our main concern is non-water weight leaving the body. In other words, carbon loss.

Since being in ketosis is the result of a high level of fat burning, we know when you are in ketosis the carbon lost through our breath are from fat. So if we are interested in Fat Loss (which most of us are) being in ketosis is a good indication you have temporarily hit a maximal rate of fat burning.

I have not seen any evidence that being in ketosis increases the amount of CO2 you expire. To the best of my knowledge you don’t breathe heavier or harder when you are in ketosis…

Based on the lack of change in expired CO2 your weight loss will remain more or less the same, with the following possible exception.

When you are in Ketosis you also breathe out ketones. You also lose ketones through your urine. The amount is small, but these are still additional carbons escaping your body that you would otherwise not be losing.

【Carbon Explanation: During Ketosis there is a small extra amount of Carbon that leaves your body, however the relevance is most likely very small.】

The only other possible explanation for increased non-water weight loss would be an increase in carbon loss through some of the fat you are eating not getting absorbed. However this has not been reported in any literature.

Bottom line is that being in Ketosis ensures that almost all the carbon leaving your body comes from fat. However there is the main difference between fasting and a high-fat ketogenic diet…

With fasting we know the carbons are coming from your body fat, since there are no other fat sources. With a ketogenic diet the Carbon will be from a mix of body fat and the fat you are eating.

You are burning a maximal amount of fat, but it is a mix of fat from your body fat, and fat from your diet.

In other words you may be burning just as much fat as when you are fasting, but the amount of fat you are burning that was once body fat may be smaller.

The only other weight loss benefit of a ketogenic diet is the amount of food you get to eat while still losing weight…

Remember that Carbohydrates are roughly 40% carbon, while fat is roughly 78%.

This means 2,000 Calories worth of carbohydrates contains roughly 200 grams of Carbon, while 2,000 calories worth of fat contains roughly 175 grams of carbon.

So someone on a ketogenic diet may be surprised that they can eat a little more than they thought they could while still losing weight... this isn't magic - It's carbon 

Bottom line: We are all losing weight every minute of every day. As long as the carbon coming in is less than the carbon going out, ANY DIET will allow for weight loss. Some diets allow for more of that weight to come from body fat than others. If the carbon balance is correct, a ketogenic diet will allow for weight loss, and for much of that weight to come from fat.

Your friend and Advocate,

Brad